The Sinister Secrets of Great Grandma Edie | Game Theory

TLDRInvestigating the dark truth behind the mysterious deaths in What Remains of Edith Finch. Is Great Grandma Edie a serial killer using a fabricated family curse as a cover? We delve into the eerie details and evidence that point to her involvement in the deaths.

Key insights

Great Grandma Edie lived longer than anyone else in the family, raising suspicions about her involvement in the deaths.

Edie's obsession with death and storytelling gives her motive and a strange connection to the tragedies.

The death stories told in the game, particularly Barbara's, contain elements that hint at Edie's possible involvement.

Walter's fear of the monster behind the door suggests that Edie may have been the real monster in the family.

The mysterious circumstances surrounding Barbara's death and Edie's unusual behavior raise questions about her true nature.

Q&A

Was Great Grandma Edie responsible for the deaths in the family?

While it is not explicitly confirmed in the game, there are several hints and clues that suggest Edie's involvement in the deaths.

What evidence points to Edie's possible guilt?

Edie's obsession with death, her bizarre connection to the death stories, and the events surrounding Barbara's death all suggest her possible involvement.

Why did the family believe in the curse?

Edie may have used the fabricated family curse as a cover for her crimes, creating a sense of fear and ensuring that no one questioned the tragic deaths.

What role did Walter play in all of this?

Walter witnessed something on the night of Barbara's death that terrified him, leading him to lock himself in a bunker for years. His fear suggests that Edie may have been the true monster in the family.

Was Edie the mastermind behind all the death stories?

While it is unclear if Edie fabricated all the death stories, her unusual behavior and the connections to the deaths raise suspicions about her true nature and involvement.

Timestamped Summary

00:00Introduction and the eerie intrigue surrounding Great Grandma Edie

03:45Exploring the family curse and the suspicious pattern of deaths

08:30Analyzing the death story of Barbara and its possible connection to Edie

13:10The strange behavior and obsessions of Great Grandma Edie

17:20Walter's fear and the suggestion of Edie being the real monster

20:45Unraveling the enigma of Great Grandma Edie and her possible involvement in the deaths